return to home page

III.G.1.a.

Comparison of levels of theory for C-Cl


Click on an entry for a histogram of the values.
The subscript refers to how many bonds of that type have been calculated.
average calculated bond lengths (Å)
Methods with predefined basis sets
semi-empirical AM1 1.6996
27
PM3 1.7282
110
PM6 1.7389
133
composite G2 1.7585
90
G3 1.7583
123
G3B3 1.7800
111
CBS-Q 1.7575
103

average calculated bond lengths (Å)
Methods with standard basis sets
STO-3G 3-21G 3-21G* 6-31G 6-31G* 6-31G** 6-31+G** 6-311G* 6-311G** 6-31G(2df,p) 6-311+G(3df,2p) TZVP cc-pVDZ cc-pVTZ cc-pVQZ aug-cc-pVDZ aug-cc-pVTZ aug-cc-pVQZ cc-pV(D+d)Z cc-pV(T+d)Z cc-pCVDZ cc-pCVTZ Sadlej_pVTZ
hartree fock HF 1.8041
129
1.8478
129
1.7727
129
1.8310
129
1.7588
133
1.7586
129
1.7614
129
1.7607
129
1.7605
123
1.7561
123
1.7526
95
1.7561
152
1.7646
129
1.7550
125
1.7285
31
1.7650
126
1.7551
120
1.7257
23
1.7836
1
1.7295
51
1.7823
1
  1.7713
11
ROHF 1.7664
10
1.8348
21
1.7568
21
1.8209
17
1.7342
21
1.7342
21
1.7305
21
1.7347
21
1.7407
17
1.6895
10
    1.7404
21
1.7284
21
1.7295
17
1.7430
17
1.7321
17
1.7282
17
         
density functional LSDA 1.8216
123
1.8258
123
1.7663
123
1.8241
123
1.7539
123
1.7551
120
1.7514
123
1.7520
123
1.7521
123
1.7464
121
    1.7549
123
1.7429
123
1.6909
9
1.7541
117
1.7333
18
1.6881
9
1.7627
1
  1.7709
1
1.7616
1
 
SVWN   1.8127
115
    1.7547
112
  1.7430
115
                               
BLYP 1.8661
129
1.8956
130
1.8165
110
1.8819
130
1.8067
130
1.8069
130
1.8047
130
1.8014
110
1.8071
124
1.7977
124
    1.8077
130
1.7981
130
  1.8174
86
    1.8164
1
  1.8247
1
1.8177
1
 
B1B95 1.8245
123
1.8307
123
1.7747
123
1.8319
123
1.7618
116
1.7604
123
1.7582
123
1.7597
123
1.7598
123
1.7534
123
    1.7622
123
1.7514
123
1.6747
11
1.7618
117
1.7612
19
1.6732
11
1.7718
1
  1.7794
1
1.7731
1
 
B3LYP 1.8410
129
1.8675
129
1.7950
129
1.8539
129
1.7814
129
1.7815
129
1.7796
129
1.7816
129
1.7629
38
1.7740
126
1.7738
88
1.7732
152
1.7838
129
1.7734
127
1.7448
23
1.7674
76
1.7515
63
1.7430
23
1.7954
1
1.7433
51
1.8036
1
1.7962
1
1.7936
11
B3LYPultrafine         1.7807
120
  1.7552
31
                               
B3PW91 1.8294
45
1.8523
127
1.7812
127
1.8384
127
1.7679
127
1.7680
127
1.7599
106
1.7664
127
1.7466
36
1.7599
121
    1.7694
127
1.7598
127
  1.7787
86
    1.7806
1
  1.7887
1
1.7807
1
 
mPW1PW91 1.8223
48
1.8458
129
1.7618
52
1.8321
129
1.7622
129
1.7623
129
1.7597
128
1.7611
129
1.7607
123
1.7549
123
    1.7642
129
1.7407
77
  1.7752
97
1.7861
8
  1.7755
1
  1.7842
1
1.7759
1
 
M06-2X 1.8389
3
1.8418
3
1.7848
3
1.8274
3
1.7445
118
1.7721
3
1.7708
3
1.7725
3
1.7725
3
1.7699
3
    1.7755
3
1.7670
3
  1.7744
3
    1.7790
1
  1.7858
1
1.7794
1
 
PBEPBE 1.8465
47
1.8690
123
1.7889
35
1.8414
35
1.7812
123
1.7813
123
1.7790
123
1.7805
123
1.7808
123
1.7722
120
1.7723
87
  1.7829
119
1.7719
121
1.6962
11
1.8074
11
1.7610
46
1.6943
11
1.7912
1
1.7107
2
1.7978
1
1.7914
1
1.7946
11
PBEPBEultrafine         1.7865
91
                                   
HSEh1PBE 1.8488
3
1.8465
3
1.7848
3
1.8324
3
1.7520
114
1.7706
3
1.7694
3
1.7707
3
1.7707
3
1.7676
3
    1.7737
3
1.7648
3
  1.7724
3
1.7634
2
  1.7745
1
  1.7824
1
1.7751
1
 
Moller Plesset perturbation MP2FC 1.8273
47
1.8767
129
1.7851
129
1.8594
129
1.7592
130
1.7535
126
1.7518
129
1.7540
128
1.7523
123
1.7334
66
  1.7544
152
1.7645
129
1.7402
85
1.7685
5
1.7546
73
1.7198
19
1.7078
3
1.7765
1
1.7234
48
1.7833
1
1.7745
1
1.7846
11
MP2FU 1.8285
41
1.8674
77
1.7743
49
1.8479
49
1.7528
129
1.7478
109
1.7455
109
1.7528
129
1.7335
38
1.7148
32
    1.7511
77
1.7154
45
1.7628
5
1.7609
21
1.7320
10
1.7361
2
1.7741
1
1.7200
51
1.7811
1
1.7707
1
 
ROMP2 1.8194
12
1.8389
15
1.7745
12
1.8486
12
1.7257
15
1.7257
15
1.7190
15
1.7231
15
1.7259
12
1.7220
12
    1.7376
15
1.7178
15
1.6816
10
1.7402
12
1.6866
10
1.5735
4
         
MP3         1.7607
116
                                   
MP4 1.8517
6
1.8845
48
    1.7516
68
    1.7317
2
1.7497
28
        1.7617
24
        1.7866
1
  1.7936
1
1.7850
1
 
B2PLYP 1.8598
3
1.8700
3
1.7968
3
1.8532
3
1.7599
114
1.7781
3
1.7571
118
1.7900
3
1.7900
3
1.7449
3
    1.7860
3
1.7713
3
  1.8206
3
    1.7885
1
  1.7948
1
1.7588
1
 
Configuration interaction CID   1.8574
45
1.7704
42
1.8408
42
1.7479
110
    1.7399
50
                             
CISD 1.8400
6
1.8621
42
1.7721
42
1.8444
42
1.7490
107
    1.7415
45
                             
Quadratic configuration interaction QCISD 1.8512
6
1.8788
118
1.7827
48
1.8600
49
1.7535
83
1.7488
49
1.7478
55
1.7520
74
1.7483
80
1.7219
27
    1.7639
46
1.7341
30
  1.8009
13
1.7855
10
  1.7854
1
1.7101
2
1.7926
1
1.7826
1
 
QCISD(T)         1.7502
41
    1.7663
6
        1.7723
26
1.7336
23
  1.7338
12
1.6566
4
      1.7958
1
1.7860
1
 
Coupled Cluster CCD 1.8497
6
1.8657
49
1.7748
43
1.8469
43
1.7547
116
1.7437
49
1.7448
50
1.7447
55
1.7355
30
1.7261
24
    1.7583
46
1.7425
24
  1.7610
26
1.7459
15
  1.7815
1
  1.7891
1
1.7798
1
 
CCSD         1.7403
64
    1.7293
2
        1.7765
10
1.7637
10
                 
CCSD(T)   1.8327
2
    1.7572
69
1.7446
7
1.7195
2
1.7340
2
1.7185
2
  1.6531
1
  1.7703
24
1.7225
30
1.8183
4
1.7698
24
1.7493
12
  1.7884
1
1.7128
2
1.7955
1
1.7858
1
 
CCSD(T)=FULL         1.7829
20
              1.7968
12
1.7781
9
1.8782
2
1.8091
11
1.8114
4
  1.7864
1
  1.7933
1
1.7097
2
 

average calculated bond lengths (Å)
Methods with effective core potentials (select basis sets)
CEP-31G CEP-31G* CEP-121G CEP-121G* LANL2DZ SDD
hartree fock HF 1.8320
129
1.7683
122
1.8308
129
1.7681
122
1.8271
129
1.8332
129
density functional B1B95 1.8414
95
1.7784
92
       
B3LYP 1.8643
129
1.7965
122
1.8614
129
1.7951
122
1.8503
129
1.8534
129
Moller Plesset perturbation MP2FC 1.8642
129
1.7719
122
1.8626
129
1.7704
122
1.8572
129
1.8667
129
For descriptions of the methods (AM1, HF, MP2, ...) and basis sets (3-21G, 3-21G*, 6-31G, ...) see the glossary in section I.C. Predefined means the basis set used is determined by the method.